I must say this was a bit of brief chapter for Christensen, but overall an intersting take on the concept of creating student portfolios. I must say I like the idea, and with the proper direction I think this could be a great and rewarding project of sorts. My only personal experience with porfolio's was my freshman year of college in English 105. We had to create a portfolio that consited of I believe 5 essays that we had written over the course of the semester, with multiple drats, and reflections as well. I remember at the time I was not too fond of the idea because I didn't have the desite to revise papers that had already been revised and handed in, but I think it was good learning experience as well.
I think portfolios are good though for students to see the amount of growth that is made from where they started and where they now have come to be. I like that Christensen seems to be very much into personal growth rather than simply sticking a grade on top. I have had professors and teachers over the years that were on both ends of the spectrum. One moment that sticks out to me though, is that for an English class I had last year in fact, I had tried my hardest the entire semester and by the time the last paper came about I was burnt out. My style of writing had greatly improved over the course of the semester, and this is something that my professor often commented on throughout my papers. When I turned in this last paper I was not satisfied and expected a very low grade, however I actually recieved a decent score. Attached to my paper was a critique along with some comments on how to improve and why I got the grade I did. My professor had told me that while this was not my best piece of writing he can still see areas that I have improved on over the course of the class, and that my improvement has been so significant that he was giving me the benefit of the doubt that this paper I simply took the safe road, and that while it was not A worthy, that he would give me a B and that I should be really proud of how much I have accomplished over the past few months.
I feel that portfolios make it possible for students to reflect, which is something that many may not do on a regular basis. I woul say with proper guidelines and allowing enough time and prep for this assignment, it would prove to be very successful and rewarding in the long run.
Tuesday, February 19, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment